Downloading PDF

Evaluating the Answer Cancer service in Greater Manchester

Evaluating the Answer Cancer service in Greater Manchester

Home » Case studies » Evaluating the Answer Cancer service in Greater Manchester

Our evaluation of the ‘Answer Cancer’ initiative increased cancer awareness in underserved communities and demonstrated good value for money. Our findings will inform future commissioning to improve cancer screening and healthcare equity in Greater Manchester.

Background

NHSE Greater Manchester Public Health Commissioning Directorate commissioned NHS Midlands and Lancashire’s (NHS ML) Improvement Unit to conduct an independent service evaluation of the ‘Answer Cancer’ service. This evaluation aimed to understand the service’s impact within the community setting. 

Answer Cancer is the programme name for the cancer screening engagement initiative, which seeks to raise cancer awareness and increase screening uptake for bowel, breast, and cervical cancers across Greater Manchester. 

The evaluation focused on the following key areas:​

• The overall impact of the service on improving cancer awareness.

• The overall impact of the service on increasing cancer screening uptake.

• Equity of service provision.

• Whether the service provides value for money.

A separate review was conducted to identify any duplication of activities with other similar service provisions.

Action

Our Improvement Unit employed a comprehensive approach to complete this independent service evaluation, which included both quantitative and qualitative analysis:

Quantitative Analysis:

• Desktop review of evidence against the programme’s key performance indicators (KPIs).

Qualitative Analysis:

• 18 semi-structured interviews with a wide range of stakeholders.

• 6 grant recipient site visits.

• Attendance at 2 external engagement/celebration events.

Impact

Answer Cancer was widely recognised amongst other similar service provisions across Greater Manchester as being highly valuable at engaging with the most difficult to reach communities. The independent service evaluation identified the following:

Answer Cancer independent service evaluation outcomes:

– Positive impact on cancer awareness: The service demonstrated a positive impact of on improving cancer awareness ​in the community.

– Challenges in measuring screening uptake: The overall impact of the service on increasing cancer screening uptake was difficult to ascertain due to limited access to quantifiable data. Some examples of increased uptake were noted from engagement work in Primary Care Networks (PCNs). 

– Equity of service provision: Equity of service provision was not substantiated as the service lacked

real-time data to inform their target areas and community groups.

– Value for money: The service was deemed to provide good value for money, with wide reach into deprived communities and the underserved population. 

Reporting and KPI’s

– Answer Cancer’s quarterly reporting to commissioners was unstructured and did not clearly demonstrate that it was meeting all the KPIs. The programme’s KPIs require revision to ensure that they best represent the intended outcomes of the service and are measurable for the service provider. 

Duplication of activities:

– Some evidence of duplication of activities with other similar service provisions was noted, although minimal. Answer Cancer is the only service provision with established links into the heart of the most deprived and underserved communities across Greater Manchester. Increased collaboration between the services was recommended. 

The independent evaluation findings will inform future commissioning decisions.

The work conducted through this evaluation has several direct and indirect benefits for patients. By improving cancer awareness within the community, patients are more likely to recognise symptoms early and seek medical advice, leading to earlier diagnoses and better treatment outcomes. Although measuring the direct impact on screening uptake was challenging, engagement efforts in specific areas showed promise, with increased screening leading to early detection of cancers, significantly improving survival rates and treatment success.

Evaluating and improving the equity of service provision ensures that underserved and deprived communities receive appropriate attention, helping to reduce health disparities. Ensuring the service provides value for money means that resources are used efficiently, maximising the benefits for the community and potentially allowing for expanded services or additional support initiatives. Recommendations for increased collaboration with other services help streamline efforts, reduce duplication, and ensure patients receive cohesive and comprehensive care.

Feedback

Excellent engagement from Kim and Andrew.  Both were very professional and supportive and keen to ensure the evaluation met our requirements. 

Lesley Elmes | Public Health Programme Manager | NHS England Greater Manchester

For more information

For more information and to learn how we can help your organisation, please contact us.

View all

News and views

News

NHS Midlands and Lancashire’s Digital Data and Technology Directorate Awarded “Towards Excellence in Digital…

We are excited to share that our Digital Data and Technology (DDaT) directorate has been formally presented with…

News

New Podcast: Revolutionising patient engagement and care with personalised healthcare videos

Join host Richard Caddy for another thought-provoking session in our latest podcast with our Digital Innovation Unit. Tune…

News

Enhancing our expertise in Workforce Planning to meet growing needs

NHS Midlands and Lancashire (ML) are excited to announce that we’ve secured five places for members of our…

View all

How we can help health systems

Business enabling services

Delivering a wide range of support functions through transactional services, business partnering and transformation that drives efficiencies and releases value and time…

Learn more about Business enabling services
Business enabling services

Clinical redesign and provider collaboration

Redesigning how health and care works across England - placing people at the centre of their own health and care and utilising…

Learn more about Clinical redesign and provider collaboration
Clinical redesign and provider collaboration

Communications and engagement

Supporting ICSs with approaches to design and deliver effective communication, engagement and behavioural insights as a key enabler for system change and…

Learn more about Communications and engagement
Communications and engagement

Developing health systems

Acting as an independent and trusted partner within the system to facilitate working across stakeholders and integrate elements of the provider system…

Learn more about Developing health systems
Developing health systems

Digitally enabled transformation and IT

Digitising care and partnering with systems for the transformation of digitally enabled service delivery (and other supporting processes) across vision, planning and…

Learn more about Digitally enabled transformation and IT
Digitally enabled transformation and IT

Personalised healthcare commissioning services

Providing end-to-end funded care services, including patients as active partners in identifying their healthcare needs and then commissioning care to meet these.…

Learn more about Personalised healthcare commissioning services
Personalised healthcare commissioning services

PHM analytics and decision support

Applying intelligence-led understanding of the health of the population to support the redesign of care and improve patient and financial outcomes across…

Learn more about PHM analytics and decision support
PHM analytics and decision support

Place and primary care transformation

Supporting providers to work together at a place and neighbourhood level to manage common resources, integrate community teams, improve health and reduce…

Learn more about Place and primary care transformation
Place and primary care transformation

Workforce resilience and transformation

Supporting systems to build a sustainable and integrated workforce, transforming systems, organisations and the workforce experience to improve resilience.

Learn more about Workforce resilience and transformation
Workforce resilience and transformation
MLCSU

Accessibility Tools